Skip to content

How to Write a Reflective Essay, With Gibbs and Kolb

How to write a reflective essay: what reflection means, the Gibbs and Kolb models, a clear structure, first-person tips and examples for nursing and education.

A reflection essay looks like the easiest assignment on the syllabus. No thesis about the causes of the French Revolution, no twelve sources, just you writing about something that happened to you. Then you sit down to write it and produce three pages of what happened, followed by one line saying you learned a lot.

That pattern is the most common reason reflective essays lose marks. Markers are not grading the story. They are grading the thinking you do about it: why the event went the way it did, what it shows about your skills or assumptions, and what you will change. This guide covers what the genre is, how the Gibbs and Kolb models give that thinking a shape, a structure you can reuse, and short examples. Every sample passage was written for this guide as an illustration.

On this page8 sections
  1. What a reflective essay actually is
  2. Descriptive writing versus reflective writing
  3. Using the Gibbs reflective cycle
  4. Using Kolb's experiential learning cycle
  5. How to structure a reflective essay
  6. How to write a reflective essay, step by step
  7. First person, tone and evidence
  8. Reflective writing mistakes markers notice

What a reflective essay actually is

A reflective essay is a piece of academic writing in which you examine an experience and explain what you learned from it. The experience might be a clinical placement shift, a teaching practice lesson, a group project, a presentation, a whole module or a book that changed your view on something. The essay moves from what happened to what it meant, and then to what happens next.

It differs from a narrative essay, which tells a story well, and from a personal statement, which argues that you are a good fit for a programme. Reflection sits between personal writing and analysis. You use "I", but you also question your own reactions and connect them to wider ideas.

Narrative essayReflective essayPersonal statement
Main goalTell a story vividlyShow what an experience taught youPersuade an admissions reader
Share of descriptionMost of the essayAbout 15 to 25 percentShort anecdotes only
Uses theory or sourcesRarelyOften, especially at universityAlmost never
Ends withA resolution or imageAn action plan or changed viewWhy you fit the programme

If your task is really an application essay, our guide to the personal statement is a better starting point. Everything below assumes a course assignment that asks you to reflect.

Descriptive writing versus reflective writing

The quickest way to improve a reflection is to see the difference between describing and reflecting at sentence level. Descriptive writing reports events. Reflective writing asks why, compares, admits uncertainty and draws a conclusion.

Descriptive
Our group presentation was on Tuesday. I did the introduction and the data slides. Some people did not prepare, and we ran over time. The tutor said our conclusion was rushed.
Reflective
We ran over time because nobody owned the timing, and I assumed someone else would. I had rehearsed my slides alone but never the handovers, which is where we lost about two minutes. Next time I will suggest one full run-through with a timer, even if it means meeting a day earlier.

The reflective version gives a cause, admits a personal assumption, and ends with a specific change. It is about the same length and no more emotional. It simply does more work per sentence.

Description versus reflection in a 1,500-word essay Description About 250 to 350 words What happenedWho, where and whenHow you felt at the timeFacts anyone presentcould report Reflection About 1,150 to 1,250 words Why it went that wayWhat theory explains itWhat you would keepWhat you will changeHow you will check it
In a 1,500-word reflection, the story takes roughly a fifth of the space.

Read each paragraph and ask: could someone who was not there have written this sentence? If yes, it is probably description. Keep it short and move on to what only you can explain.

Using the Gibbs reflective cycle

Graham Gibbs set out his reflective cycle in 1988, and nursing, midwifery and social work programmes often ask for it. It works best for one specific event: a difficult conversation, a mistake, a shift that went well for reasons worth understanding. The six stages map neatly onto paragraphs.

The Gibbs reflective cycle (1988) 1. Description What happened? 2. Feelings What did you think? 3. Evaluation What went well or badly? 4. Analysis Why did it go that way? 5. Conclusion What did you learn? 6. Action plan What will you change? Analysis is the longest stage
Gibbs moves from what happened to what you will change. Analysis carries the most weight.
  1. Description: what happened, who was involved, where and when. Keep it factual and brief.
  2. Feelings: what you were thinking and feeling at the time. Be honest, and keep this short too.
  3. Evaluation: what went well and what went badly. Give both sides, even for an event that felt like a failure.
  4. Analysis: why things went that way. This is where theory, guidelines or reading come in, and it should be the longest stage.
  5. Conclusion: what you learned and what else you could have done.
  6. Action plan: what you will do differently next time, and how you will check that you did.

A common mistake is giving each stage equal space. Description and feelings together should take up less room than analysis alone. If your marker sees six even blocks, they will usually conclude that the analysis is thin.

Illustrative example: Gibbs analysis paragraph (nursing)
I hesitated to escalate the patient's rising respiratory rate because her other observations were stable and I did not want to seem alarmist to the senior nurse. Looking back, this was a case of anchoring on the reassuring numbers. The early warning score my placement uses is designed to remove exactly this judgement call: the score triggered a review, and my role was to report it, not to second-guess it. I now see escalation as part of the protocol rather than a personal opinion I need to defend.

Using Kolb's experiential learning cycle

David Kolb's model, published in 1984, has four stages and treats learning as a loop you go around repeatedly. It suits reflections on something that unfolded over weeks: a module, a placement, a research project or learning a new skill. Education and business courses often prefer it.

Kolb's experiential learning cycle (1984) Concrete experience You do something Reflective observation You look back on it Abstract concepts You explain it with theory Active experimentation You try a new approach Each test becomes the next experience
In Kolb's cycle, the new approach you test becomes the next experience to reflect on.

The strength of Kolb is that you can show two or three turns of the cycle in one essay. Your first lesson went badly, you read about behaviour management, you tried a new routine, and the second lesson went differently. That progression is far more convincing than a single event with a promise attached.

Choosing between the two is usually simple. Pick Gibbs when the essay is about one incident and your course cares about feelings, since Gibbs gives them a stage of their own. Pick Kolb when the learning happened across several attempts and you can show what changed between them. Gibbs ends with a plan; Kolb ends with a test of that plan.

Other models exist, such as Driscoll's "What? So what? Now what?" and Schön's reflection-in-action and reflection-on-action. If your brief names a model, use that one and use its stage names as headings or signposts. If it names none, Driscoll's three questions are the lightest structure for a short piece.

Illustrative example: Kolb, abstract conceptualisation (education)
My Year 8 class lost focus every time I handed out worksheets, which took around four minutes. Reading about transitions in classroom management, I realised that dead time invites off-task talk, however engaging the main activity is. In the following lesson I placed worksheets on desks before students arrived. The opening activity started within a minute, and I had to redirect noticeably fewer students. One lesson is not proof, so I plan to keep this routine for three weeks and note any changes.

How to structure a reflective essay

Whether or not you follow a named model, a reflective essay still needs an introduction, a body and a conclusion. The difference is what each part does. For a 1,500-word essay, a workable split looks like this:

  • Introduction, about 150 words: names the experience, the model you are using and the main thing you learned.
  • Description and feelings, about 250 to 300 words: sets the scene, briefly and factually.
  • Evaluation and analysis, about 700 words: explains why it went that way, with theory or course ideas.
  • Conclusion and action plan, about 300 words: states the learning and the concrete next step.

A reflective essay can have a thesis. It is usually one sentence at the end of the introduction that states what the experience taught you, for example: "This placement showed me that clear handovers matter more to patient safety than speed." Our guide on how to write a thesis statement covers the mechanics, and the same rules apply: specific, arguable, and supported by the body.

The opening sentence should take the reader straight to the experience or to the question it raised. A dictionary definition of reflection tells the marker nothing about you. These openings work better:

  • The moment of uncertainty: "Ten minutes into my first observed lesson, I realised half the class had not understood the task."
  • The assumption you later dropped: "I went into my first placement believing that good nurses never ask for help."
  • The outcome, with the explanation promised: "Our group missed its first deadline by four days, and the reason was not laziness."
Illustrative outline: reflection on a failed group project
Intro: second-year marketing project, Kolb's cycle, main learning about shared deadlines. Experience: the team missed the draft deadline by four days. Observation: tasks were split on day one, but nobody tracked progress. Concepts: Tuckman's stages of group development; we skipped the norming stage. Experiment: in the next module I proposed a weekly fifteen-minute check-in, and we submitted on time. Conclusion: structure early saves conflict later; plan to use a shared task board in my dissertation group.

How to write a reflective essay, step by step

This process gets most students from a blank page to a submitted draft without the three-pages-of-plot problem.

  1. Read the brief for the model, the word count and whether theory is expected. A 500-word reflection rarely needs references; a 2,500-word nursing reflection usually does.
  2. Pick an experience with a real lesson in it: a moment where you were uncertain, made a choice or changed your mind. A shift where nothing happened is hard to reflect on.
  3. Free-write for fifteen minutes before you structure anything. What surprised you, what would you do again, what did you not understand at the time?
  4. Sort the notes into the stages of your model. Empty stages show you where the thinking is missing.
  5. Find one or two sources for the analysis, such as a course reading, a clinical guideline or a theory from lectures. The source should explain your experience, not decorate it.
  6. Draft the analysis first. It is the hardest and most valuable part, and the introduction is easier once you know what you concluded.
  7. Write an action plan you could check later. Replace "I will communicate better" with "I will summarise each handover back to the outgoing nurse".
  8. Cut description in the edit. If the essay runs long, trim the story first.

Free-writing feels like a detour, and it is the step most people skip. It is also where the honest material turns up, because nobody is marking it yet.

For the opening paragraph itself, our guide on how to write an introduction paragraph has templates that adapt well to reflection. For the last paragraph, see how to write a conclusion.

First person, tone and evidence

Reflective essays are one of the few academic forms where "I" is expected rather than tolerated. Writing "it was felt that the session went poorly" about your own lesson sounds like a press release from a very shy government department. Say "I felt the session went poorly" and then explain why.

First person does not mean informal. Keep the register academic: no slang, no exclamation marks, and no long passages about emotions. Feelings belong in the essay when they influenced what you did. Anxiety that made you skip a question in a ward round is relevant; a general note that you were tired is not.

  • Use "I" for your actions, thoughts and conclusions
  • Use past tense for the experience and present tense for what you now understand
  • Support claims about practice with a source, guideline or course concept
  • Admit mistakes plainly, then explain them
  • Avoid absolute claims such as "I now know exactly how to handle conflict"
  • Keep patients, pupils, clients and placement sites anonymous

Citations follow the style your course uses. Many nursing and education programmes use APA or Harvard; our essay format guide shows how the main styles set out references.

Illustrative example: end-of-course reflection (Driscoll)
What? I began this statistics module convinced I was "not a maths person". So what? My first two problem sets were weak because I avoided office hours, assuming questions would expose how far behind I was. When I finally went, the tutor showed me that most of my errors came from one misunderstanding about standard deviation. Now what? In my research methods module next term, I will book a session in week two instead of week eight.

Reflective writing mistakes markers notice

Most weak reflections share a few problems, and each has a direct fix:

  • Too much story. If description passes about a quarter of the essay, the analysis is being squeezed. Cut the scene-setting first.
  • Vague learning. "I learned the importance of teamwork" says nothing. Name what you will do differently and when.
  • Theory as decoration. Mentioning Tuckman or Maslow without linking them to your event adds words, not marks. Show how the theory explains what happened.
  • Only the positives. A reflection where everything went well reads as unreflective. Even successful events have something you would adjust.
  • Identifying people. In nursing, social work and teaching, leave out the names of patients, clients, pupils and placement sites, and follow your programme's confidentiality guidance.
  • Missing stages. If the brief asks for Gibbs, a marker will look for all six. Use signposts so they can find them quickly.

Small, specific moments make better reflections than big dramatic events, because you can analyse them properly within the word count.

Reflection is easy to misjudge in your own draft, because you were there and the gaps feel filled in. A second reader helps. Our essay editing service can point out where description crowds out analysis, and if you want a model to study, see custom essay support.

FAQ

What is a reflective essay?

A reflective essay is academic writing in which you examine a personal experience and explain what you learned from it. It moves from a short description of what happened to an analysis of why it happened that way and what it means for your future practice. Most university versions also connect the experience to theory or course concepts. It is written in the first person but keeps an academic tone.

How do you start a reflective essay?

Open with the experience itself or the question it raised, not a definition of reflection. A good first line places the reader at a specific moment, such as the point where you realised a lesson plan was not working. Then name the reflective model if your brief requires one and state your main learning in a sentence. That last sentence works like a thesis and helps the marker follow the rest of the essay.

Can I use "I" in a reflective essay?

Yes, and you should. Reflective writing is about your own thinking, so the first person is expected in almost every course that sets it. Passive constructions such as "it was felt" make the writing vague and can suggest you are avoiding responsibility for your choices. Keep the rest of the register academic: clear sentences, no slang and claims supported by reasons or sources.

What is the difference between Gibbs and Kolb?

Gibbs has six stages and is built around one specific event, with a dedicated stage for feelings and an action plan at the end. Kolb has four stages and treats learning as a cycle you can go around several times, which suits experiences that develop over weeks. Nursing and social work programmes tend to ask for Gibbs, while education and business courses often use Kolb. If your brief names neither, choose Gibbs for a single incident and Kolb for a module or placement.

How long should the description be in a reflective essay?

Keep description to roughly 15 to 25 percent of the word count. In a 1,500-word essay that is about 250 to 350 words for what happened and how you felt. The rest should go on evaluation, analysis and your action plan, because that is where markers look for reflective thinking. If your draft is over length, trimming the story is usually the safest cut.

How do you end a reflective essay?

End with what you learned and a specific action you will take. A strong action plan is something you could check later, such as booking tutor support in week two or summarising every handover back to the colleague giving it. Avoid closing with a general statement that the experience taught you a lot. If the model is Kolb, you can end by describing how you tested the new approach and what you will try next.