Netflix in 2022: Stalled Growth and the Problem of Account Sharing
Background
Netflix began as a DVD rental service and became the largest subscription streaming service in the world. By the end of the first quarter of 2022, it reported about 222 million paying households (Netflix, 2022). For most of its history, the company grew by adding members each quarter, and investors treated membership growth as the main measure of its health. In its own words, the COVID-19 pandemic significantly increased growth in 2020, which made the slowdown that followed harder to read (Netflix, 2022). This case examines the situation Netflix faced in April 2022 and the choices available to management at that point.
Problem statement
In its first-quarter 2022 letter to shareholders, Netflix reported paid net additions of minus 0.2 million, against its own forecast of plus 2.5 million, and forecast a further loss of 2.0 million members in the second quarter (Netflix, 2022). The company pointed to slow acquisition across all regions, recent price changes, the suspension of service in Russia and competition from new streaming services. It also disclosed that, in addition to its paying households, Netflix was being shared with more than 100 million additional households, including over 30 million in the United States and Canada (Netflix, 2022). The core problem was therefore not weak demand for the product. Many people were watching Netflix without paying for it, and the company had few levers left to grow revenue in mature markets.
Analysis: Porter's five forces
Porter's (2008) five forces framework helps explain why growth had become harder. Rivalry among existing competitors was high: Netflix itself named linear TV, YouTube, Amazon and Hulu as long-standing competitors and noted that many traditional entertainment companies had launched streaming services over the previous three years (Netflix, 2022). The threat of substitutes was also high, since free video platforms and live television compete for the same viewing time. Buyer power was considerable because subscribers can cancel a monthly plan at any time with little switching cost. Supplier power was mixed: original programming reduced Netflix's dependence on licensed titles, but the studios launching rival services were also content owners that could keep their libraries for their own platforms. The threat of new entrants was moderate, because building a global library requires large and sustained content spending. Taken together, the forces describe an industry where price increases alone carry a real risk of cancellations.
Analysis: SWOT summary
A brief SWOT analysis adds the company's internal position to this industry view. Its strengths were scale, a global library of original programming and profitability: the company stated it would hold its operating margin at around 20% while it worked to reaccelerate revenue growth (Netflix, 2022). Its main weakness was a business model that depended almost entirely on subscription fees, which left membership growth as the only route to higher revenue once prices could not rise further. The largest opportunity was the more than 100 million households already watching through someone else's account, since these viewers already valued the service. The most serious threats were the growing number of rival services and the macroeconomic pressure the company cited in Latin America and Central and Eastern Europe (Netflix, 2022). The SWOT therefore points to the same conclusion as the five forces: the next stage of growth had to come from monetizing existing viewers and widening price options, not from charging current members more.
Alternatives
Management had at least three realistic options. The first was to raise prices again across all plans. This would increase average revenue per member quickly, but the first-quarter letter already attributed the loss of 0.6 million members in the United States and Canada largely to a recent price change, so further increases risked more cancellations (Netflix, 2022). The second was to introduce a lower-priced plan supported by advertising. This could attract price-sensitive viewers and open a new revenue stream, but Netflix had no advertising business and would need partners, measurement tools and content rights that allowed ads. The third was to convert shared accounts into paying ones, building on the paid sharing features Netflix had introduced in three Latin American markets in March 2022 (Netflix, 2022). This targeted the 100 million sharing households directly but could frustrate existing members who were used to sharing freely.
Recommendation
Netflix should combine the second and third alternatives: launch a low-priced advertising plan first, then roll out paid sharing. The order matters. An advertising plan gives people who are asked to stop borrowing an account a cheaper way to join, which reduces the risk that the change simply pushes them away. Paid sharing then converts part of the large base of non-paying viewers into revenue, either as new accounts or as extra members added to existing accounts. Raising prices alone should be avoided because, given the high buyer power identified in the five forces analysis, it would put pressure on retention without reaching the households that already watch for free.
Implementation and outcome
Implementation should proceed in stages, with tests in a limited set of markets before a wider rollout and clear metrics for sign-ups, cancellations and revenue per member. The advertising plan needs an ad sales partner, limits on how many ads appear per hour and a review of which licensed titles can carry ads. Paid sharing needs simple tools that let members move a profile to a new account or add an extra member, so the change feels like a choice rather than a penalty. Communication should explain the rules before enforcement begins. This is broadly the path Netflix followed. In October 2022, the company announced Basic with Ads at $6.99 per month in the United States, launching on November 3, 2022, in 12 countries (Peters, 2022). In May 2023, it launched paid sharing in more than 100 countries, representing more than 80% of its revenue base (Netflix, 2023). In the second quarter of 2023, Netflix reported 5.89 million paid net additions and 238.39 million paid memberships, up 8% year over year (Netflix, 2023). The same letter noted that advertising revenue was not yet material, which suggests the ad plan served mainly as an entry point at that stage. The results support the recommendation, although later performance would depend on how well the company retained the members it gained.
References
- Netflix, Inc. (2022, April 19). Q1 2022 letter to shareholders [Exhibit 99.1 to Form 8-K]. U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission. https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1065280/000106528022000144/ex991_q122.htm
- Netflix, Inc. (2023, July 19). Q2 2023 letter to shareholders [Exhibit 99.1 to Form 8-K]. U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission. https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1065280/000106528023000197/ex991_q223.htm
- Peters, G. (2022, October 13). Netflix starting from $6.99 a month. Netflix. https://about.netflix.com/en/news/announcing-basic-with-ads-us
- Porter, M. E. (2008). The five competitive forces that shape strategy. Harvard Business Review, 86(1), 78–93.