Drought, Plow and Policy: Rethinking the Causes of the Dust Bowl
Introduction
In the 1930s, dust storms on the southern Great Plains stripped topsoil from farms and drove families from the land. For decades the Dust Bowl has been told as a moral story: farmers plowed up grassland that should never have been broken, and nature struck back. That story has been challenged from two directions. Climate scientists have shown that the drought itself had causes far from the Plains, and some historians have questioned whether farming truly ruined the region. This paper argues that the Dust Bowl is best understood as a drought that began in the oceans and was made far worse by land use, and that the strongest recent evidence supports neither a purely natural nor a purely human explanation.
Sources and Approach
The debate over the Dust Bowl now involves three kinds of evidence, and each answers a different question. Environmental historians ask how farming culture and economics shaped the use of the land. Climate scientists use models to test what caused the drought and what made it more intense. Economic historians measure what the erosion did to land values and population over the following decades. Reading these sources together shows where they agree and where their disagreements are smaller than they seem. This paper first sets out the environmental critique, then the evidence that points to drought and to the resilience of Plains farming, and then a study that connects the two before turning to the long-term consequences.
The Environmental Critique
The most influential account of the disaster is Donald Worster's Dust Bowl: The Southern Plains in the 1930s, first published in 1979 and reissued in a twenty-fifth anniversary edition in 2004. Worster argues that the Dust Bowl was not simply bad luck. In his reading, a commercial farming culture treated the grassland as a resource to be exploited for profit, and the expansion of wheat farming in the decades before the crash put large areas under the plow with little thought for what would hold the soil in a dry year. When drought arrived, the exposed ground blew away. For Worster, the storms were the predictable result of an economic system, and the lesson concerned the culture that produced them as much as the weather.
Timothy Egan's The Worst Hard Time, a narrative history that won the National Book Award for nonfiction in 2006, gives this critique a human face. Egan follows families who stayed on the southern Plains through the worst years, and his account shows how a boom in land and wheat drew settlers onto marginal ground before economic collapse and drought arrived together. Egan's book is not a quantitative study, but it shows the reader what Worster's argument meant for the people who lived through it.
The Case for Drought
Climate research complicates the picture by locating the drought's origins in the oceans. Using atmospheric models, Siegfried Schubert and colleagues found that the 1930s drought was caused by anomalous tropical sea surface temperatures during the decade, and that interactions between the atmosphere and the land surface made it more severe (Schubert et al.). Their study notes that the drought affected almost two-thirds of the United States and parts of Mexico and Canada. If the drought was set in motion by ocean conditions, then plowing alone cannot explain why the 1930s were so dry.
The historian Geoff Cunfer reaches a related conclusion from a different direction. In On the Great Plains: Agriculture and Environment, Cunfer combines agricultural census data with geographic information systems to map land use in hundreds of Plains counties across more than a century. He finds that land use stayed broadly stable through the twentieth century and that much of the region remained in native grassland. On this evidence, the Dust Bowl looks less like proof that farming had destroyed the Plains and more like a severe but temporary disruption in a farming system that recovered. Cunfer's work challenges Worster directly: if much of the land was never plowed, a story of total ruin is hard to sustain.
Reconciling the Evidence
These accounts are less opposed than they first appear. A 2009 study by Benjamin Cook, Ron Miller and Richard Seager tested what happens in a climate model when the effects of crop failure, represented as reduced vegetation and a new source of soil dust, are added to the ocean temperatures of the 1930s. Ocean forcing alone produced a drought centred in the southwest and without the warming observed in the middle of the continent. When land degradation was included, the simulated drought grew stronger and moved north, much closer to what was actually observed. The authors conclude that human-induced land degradation likely contributed to the dust storms and also amplified the drought, turning a modest drought driven by sea surface temperatures into one of the worst environmental disasters in the history of the United States (Cook et al.). This finding supports Schubert's account of where the drought began and Worster's claim that land use made it catastrophic.
The same study offers a way to read Cunfer's data. A disaster does not require that every acre be plowed. If degraded fields in part of the region produced enough dust to change the regional climate, then a minority of broken land could still have had effects across the whole Plains. Worster may overstate how completely farming transformed the region, and Cunfer may understate how much damage a limited area of plowed and abandoned land could do.
Consequences
The economic record shows why the causes matter. Richard Hornbeck's study of Plains counties found that farmland values and agricultural revenues fell sharply in more-eroded counties compared with less-eroded ones, and that the decline was immediate and lasting. Farmers adjusted their land use only slightly through the Depression and into the 1950s. Most of the adjustment came instead through population loss, as residents left the more-eroded counties (Hornbeck). Erosion, in other words, was not a temporary setback for the places where it was worst. It changed where people lived for a generation.
Conclusion
The Dust Bowl does not fit neatly into either a story of human folly or a story of natural disaster. The drought began with ocean conditions that no farmer could control, as Schubert and his co-authors showed. Yet the climate modelling of Cook, Miller and Seager indicates that degraded farmland made the drought worse and helped produce the dust storms that defined the decade, and Hornbeck's economic evidence shows that the damage lasted long after the rain returned. Worster's critique of land use survives this evidence in a more limited form, and Cunfer's corrective makes it more precise. The most accurate account is a combined one: an ordinary drought became a historic disaster because of what had been done to the land.
Works Cited
- Cook, Benjamin I., et al. "Amplification of the North American 'Dust Bowl' Drought through Human-Induced Land Degradation." <i>Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences</i>, vol. 106, no. 13, 2009, pp. 4997–5001, https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.0810200106.
- Cunfer, Geoff. <i>On the Great Plains: Agriculture and Environment</i>. Texas A&M UP, 2005.
- Egan, Timothy. <i>The Worst Hard Time: The Untold Story of Those Who Survived the Great American Dust Bowl</i>. Houghton Mifflin, 2006.
- Hornbeck, Richard. "The Enduring Impact of the American Dust Bowl: Short- and Long-Run Adjustments to Environmental Catastrophe." <i>American Economic Review</i>, vol. 102, no. 4, 2012, pp. 1477–507, https://doi.org/10.1257/aer.102.4.1477.
- Schubert, Siegfried D., et al. "On the Cause of the 1930s Dust Bowl." <i>Science</i>, vol. 303, no. 5665, 2004, pp. 1855–59, https://doi.org/10.1126/science.1095048.
- Worster, Donald. <i>Dust Bowl: The Southern Plains in the 1930s</i>. 25th anniversary ed., Oxford UP, 2004.